I will mention the other two cards they were football and the BatStamp again on my regular card blog but not here since they are not Curly W Cards they aren't even DC sports. Turns out the incoming copy (listed as "Sharp" in the auction) what I would call Excellent or Near Excellent is in better shape than the one I had. So it is an unintentional upgrade.
The card is 1963 Topps Baseball 69 Bud Zipfel Senators.
1963 Topps Baseball 69 Bud Zipfel - My Original copy on the left, replacement on right.
(Front and Back)
Here is my original copy front and back:
Followed by the replacement copy front and back:
So all was not lost.